I s’pose many, if not most of you readin’ this are ‘cowboy movie’ fans to some extent. With quasi-historical portrayals I expect some creative license, but the majority of these portrayals are completely off the wall.
Apparently few have paid any attention to the actual history and location (terrain) of these events. Clothing and firearms are displayed that are far in advance of the period depicted, or in some instances never used at all. The original ‘characters’ and events are so good, so unique, that few screen writers or directors could enhance them.
What screen writer could come up with names like “Wyatt Earp, Doc Holliday, Ike Clanton, Johnny Ringo, Big Nose Kate, Buckskin Frank, Bat Masterson, Wild Bill Hickok, Commodore Perry Owen or Curly Bill?” What screen writer could dream up the events of their lives? What director could ‘improve’ on the historical background of these events?
bravenet.com